Skip to product information
1 of 2

Sugar Cookie Edible Cookie Dough

Sugar Cookie Edible Cookie Dough

Regular price $8.00 USD
Regular price $9.00 USD Sale price $8.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Flavor: Sugar Cookie - A white sugar dough made with pure vanilla extract.

The edible cookie dough that made Cookie Dough Creamery so popular and made Kelly famous.

Our customers went without our edible cookie doughs for six years after we had to close in 2020. Thousands of them demanded hard on our social media pages that we begin making and selling it again.

We eventually gave in to their demands and stopped saying no. Now we are making our edible cookie doughs again and shipping it nationwide.

What makes our edible cookie dough so special? It's not just the great, made with real butter taste... but it's also the great texture. Our edible cookie dough keeps a soft and smooth texture when refrigerated. It's almost like ice cream, except it's not frozen... it's refrigerated. It's like "fridge cream"!

Made with heat-treated flour and no eggs, this dough is crafted specifically for eating raw. 

How to store: Store refrigerated for up to 3 months. Or store in the freezer for up to 12 months. 

How to bake: DON'T! There are no eggs in this dough so it won't rise when baked. It will just result in a flat mess. It's meant to be eaten as raw cookie dough. 

INGREDIENTS: HEAT TREATED WHEAT FLOUR, SUGAR, BUTTER, GLUCOSE SYRUP, WATER, VANILLA EXTRACT (WATER, ETHYL ALCOHOL, VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES), & SALT. 

NET WT 10oz (283g) - Keep Refrigerated

.

Size of purchase: this 10 ounce tub is approximately the same weight as 2 Crumbl cookies, or 6 to 7 typically sized baked cookies.

.

Local Delivery Orders: We do delivery routes to areas around Columbus, Ohio two to three times a week. If your address is on a delivery route, you will see the day the route is scheduled when you check out. Deliveries are made during the day and left at your door.

Local delivery customers can add this Insulated Bag with Ice Packs to your order to keep your cookie dough chilled at your door until you get home.

.

UPS Shipping Orders: If your address is not on a delivery route, UPS shipping will be presented to you during checkout.

All UPS Shipped orders are packed in insulation with ice packs.

.

Pickup at David & Mary's 7 days a week: Our edible cookie doughs are available in the fridges at David & Mary's in Lewis Center. Please call them to confirm what flavors they have in stock.

.

Question: What if I am not home to receive the delivery? Will the product spoil because it’s not refrigerated? 

Answer: No, it won’t, unless you leave it out for days. The ingredient in our edible cookie dough that is at risk of spoiling is butter. The US Department of Agriculture says that butter can be left out for a couple of days without spoiling. Our edible cookie dough is fine if we deliver it and it doesn’t make it into the fridge until later that night. We do however recommend that you serve it at a refrigerated temperature, given it will be a runny consistency at room temperature.

View full details
  • 5 stars: 15 (94%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (6%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
J
Jordan (United States)

Sugar cookie is definitely my favorite flavor! It’s the perfect sweet snack

R
Rachel Westrick (United States)

The best. So glad they are back

K
Kelly Long (United States)

Nice texture and great flavor!

A
Anonymous

Great!

A
Amber Fiore (United States)

Absolutely incredible treat!! My family loves cookie dough and Kelly’s is now at the top of our list! Delicious.. every flavor!

H
Holly Wasielewski (United States)

Love the sugar cookie dough! So smooth and creamy.

A
Anonymous (United States)

Ahhhh just like I remember!!! De freaking licious! So glad you are back and I can’t wait to order more!!!

C
Cassie A (United States)

These were amazing. They didn't have a chance with my family. We can wait to order more

A
Anonymous (United States)

Amazing!! Spot on flavor and texture.

C
Collin McCarty (United States)

So happy with the order and that you guys are back!!

J
Jennifer Peeke (United States)

Once again, just as I remember from the Cookie Dough Creamery days. I remembered why it was my second favorite flavor(only behind Chocolate Chip!)

A
Anonymous (United States)

It was delivered on time and all 3 flavors (chocolate chip cookie, cookies and cream and sugar cookie) were delicious!

T
Tammy Alspach (United States)

It was very good just like I remembered but the peanut butter was my favorite. I was not disappointed with any of them. I can't wait for the other flavors to be available

V
Victoria Nelson (United States)

Amazing!

C
Cheryl Caudill (United States)

So glad you are back

A
Anonymous (United States)

It was just how my son remembered! He is so excited you are back!

We launched KellysFamous.com on January 16th, 2026. The sales numbers below are updated numerous times each day.